NPS vs UPS
The same comparison the NPS Trust UPS calculator makes, for the same person and the same assumptions. Change the inputs in the UPS calculator; this page updates.
NPS and UPS are structurally different. NPS outcomes depend on market returns and annuity rates, which are not guaranteed. UPS payout is set by formula and depends on qualifying service and on your Individual Corpus against the Benchmark Corpus. Results are indicative.
Monthly Payout after Superannuation
Lumpsum Payment
| UPS | NPS |
|---|
How the schemes differ
| Point | NPS (Government sector) | UPS |
|---|---|---|
| Contribution | Employee 10% of basic + DA; Government 14% | Employee 10%; Government 10% to the individual corpus and 8.5% to a pool corpus |
| Corpus | Your individual corpus, invested in the market | Individual corpus, compared with a Benchmark Corpus at retirement |
| Retirement payout | Annuity bought with the corpus left after withdrawal | Assured payout: 50% of 12-month average basic at 25 years, proportionate from 10 years |
| Monthly pension | Depends on corpus and annuity rate; not indexed | Formula, × (Individual ÷ Benchmark Corpus) × (1 − final withdrawal), plus DR |
| Lump sum | Final withdrawal only | Final withdrawal (reduces payout) plus one-tenth of pay + DA per six months of service |
| Family benefit | Depends on the annuity option chosen | 60% of the payout to the spouse, with DR |
| Dearness Relief | Not paid on annuity | Paid on payout and family payout |
| Partial withdrawals | Allowed for specified purposes, from own contributions | Allowed; they reduce the Individual Corpus and so the payout |
| Final withdrawal | Up to 60% above ₹12 lakh; full withdrawal up to ₹8 lakh | Up to 60% of the lower of Individual or Benchmark Corpus |
| Tax treatment | Check current Income-tax provisions | Check current Income-tax provisions |
| Investment risk | Borne by you | Payout set by formula; corpus shortfall reduces it |
| Eligibility | Government employees appointed from 1 January 2004 | Option for Central Government NPS employees; payout needs at least 10 years' qualifying service |