Home / Knowledge Centre / CCS (CCA) Rules
After the inquiry report: disagreement, further inquiry and your representation
The inquiry report is not the final word. The Disciplinary Authority can accept it, disagree with it, or send it back. You have the right to see it and respond before any penalty is decided.
Last updated 11 Nov 2026 · 5 min read
Relevant provision
Rule 15 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965: Rule 15(1) (remitting for further inquiry) and Rule 15(2) (copy of the report and representation).
Two questions the Disciplinary Authority must ask
- Was the inquiry held as the rules and natural justice require, giving you a reasonable opportunity?
- Are the findings acceptable on the evidence?
Disagreeing with the Inquiring Authority
The findings are not binding on the Disciplinary Authority. It may disagree, but it must record its reasons, send you a copy of the report together with those reasons, and consider your representation before deciding.
Further inquiry, not a fresh one
Under Rule 15(1) the case can be sent back for further inquiry, generally to the same Inquiring Authority, for example where an important witness was not examined. The rules do not allow earlier inquiries to be set aside and fresh ones ordered just because a report exonerating you is not liked. In K.R. Deb v. Collector of Central Excise (1971), the Supreme Court quashed a dismissal after three successive inquiries and called the procedure harassment.
Your representation under Rule 15(2)
You get a copy of the report, and any disagreement note, and can submit a representation, generally within 15 days. Point out procedural lapses, evidence that does not support the findings, and why the proposed view is wrong.
Practical example
An Inquiry Officer finds a charge not proved. The Disciplinary Authority disagrees but sends no reasons and imposes a penalty. The order is open to challenge because the employee was not given the disagreement note and a chance to represent.
Illustrative example, not a real case.
Common mistakes
- Not responding to the inquiry report within the time given
- Repeating the defence instead of answering the specific points of disagreement
- Not objecting when a fresh inquiry is ordered after a favourable report
Important precautions
- Ask for the complete inquiry report and all exhibits
- Answer each finding and each point of disagreement separately
- Keep a copy and acknowledgement of your representation
Source
- Handbook for Inquiry Officers and Disciplinary Authorities (Dec 2024 edition) – ISTM, DoPT
- CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 – Department of Personnel and Training rules page
Based on the ISTM Handbook (2013). Later amendments may have changed some details; check the current rules and DoPT orders.
General information, not legal advice. Check the current text of the rules and any later amendments.